• Welcome to BookAndReader!

    We LOVE books and hope you'll join us in sharing your favorites and experiences along with your love of reading with our community. Registering for our site is free and easy, just CLICK HERE!

    Already a member and forgot your password? Click here.

Dissertation Topic

Cath'spiano

New Member
Dear all,

I am an English student about to go into my third year and am aganizing over my dissertation texts. I think that I would like to write about texts which contain childhood difficulties, which are both humorous and serious. I have read Curious incident of the dog and am considering this. I have thought about Angerla's Ashes and Life is not all ha ha hee hee. Does anyone have any other suggestions?

Cath
 
angelas ashes is really good,but if you want books about chilhood difficulties try these books written by dave pelzer,a child called it,the lost boy and a man named dave,its his life story,its heartbreaking stuff,you would get so much for your dissertation out of these! but have hankies at the ready cause you will need them!
 
Cath'spiano said:
I have read Curious incident of the dog and am considering this.

I would ditch this and consider an adult book; although I know the language was simple intentionally and that adults read it, I still feel that it was more of a kids' book than one for adults.

Or, if you can, don't focus on one book, but cover the portrayal of children with learning/living difficulties in literature which gives you a wider scope.
 
Thank you

Thank you very much for your quick reply. I saw those books you mentioned when I was searching on the internet, and it's interesting to know that other people would recommend them for the same purpose. I would prefer to choose books that are already available in shops rather than order them, so I can get a good feel for them before I make any decisions. Hopefully I will be able to find some of these.
 
I agree completely with Ruby on the Pelzer stories - you would have enough material for two dissertations there!

I'm tempted to agree with Stewart on rejecting Haddon's "The curious incident of the dog in the night time" but for different reasons. I have taught AS children, and Haddon captures the attitudes and behavioural traits of an intelligent AS child pretty well. However, unless you want to focus on one aspect of behaviour then it is hardly typical.

Geoff
 
Carolyn See: "Dreaming: Hard Luck and Good Times in America"
The story of a harrowing childhood, complete with alcoholic mom and dad, lunatic relatives, wacked-out ex-husbands, a wild ride through the 1960s, all related by a woman who has come through it all and out the other side, and lived to tell about it with humor and grace. Love, love, love this book.

Tobias Wolff: "This Boy's Life"
Another harrowing childhood, but a much darker story, I thought. Worth the read.
 
I also suggest:

Running with Scissors by Augusten Burroughs. Just read this and it has both humor and pathos and much childhood difficulty.

The Liar's Club by Mary Karr.

The first book of the Patrick Melrose Trilogy by Edward St. Aubyn.

Motherless Brooklyn by Jonathan Lethem (and his new book as well, though I don't remember the title).

extracredibly Loud/close by Safran Foer, which I haven't read but it's definitely in the category.



This is such a broad and full area, it would probably be a very good idea to narrow it down. These books come immediately to mind, but there are really thousands that fall into this category.

What kind of "childhood difficulty," for example? Illness, family trauma, war . . there's so much out there. It seems like almost every memoir I can think of has at least a bit of that. I think you might want to narrow your subject by a lot. For instance, "near death experiences in childhood in English literature" or "war from a child's perspective in English literature" Also, I guess I'm assuming your talking about the whole English language, whereas, it might help to narrow the field to British writers or American writers or British/colonial.
 
I torally agree with the pelzer recommendations. I want to add, though, The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd. It is a coming of age story about a young teen girl in the pre-civil rights south and her coming to terms with her mothers death. A non-fiction recommendation I have is An Hour Before Daylight, by Jimmy Carter, about his childhood, growing up in the poor rural south.
 
I would recommend, to go alongside Angela's Ashes (which by the way is a great book) Roddy Doyle's Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha.
I also think that something like I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings, or Roll of Thunder Hear my Cry, which also deal with other issues surrounding the protagonist's personal childhood, might be quite interesting.
You could, if you wanted to branch out, read some books that follow the childhood adventures in earlier centuries, perhaps ones written for children even, to get a broader perspective - like What Katy Did, Anne of Green Gables.
 
try this

a star called henry:

first chapter excerpt:

My mother looked up at the stars. There were plenty of them up there. She lifted her hand. It swayed as she chose one. Her finger pointed.

—There's my little Henry up there. Look it.

I looked, her other little Henry sitting beside her on the step. I looked up and hated him. She held me but she looked up at her twinkling boy. Poor me beside her, pale and red-eyed, held together by rashes and sores. A stomach crying to be filled, bare feet aching like an old, old man's. Me, a shocking substitute for the little Henry who'd been too good for this world, the Henry God had wanted for himself. Poor me.

And poor Mother. She sat on that step and other crumbling steps and watched her other babies joining Henry. Little Gracie, Lil, Victor, another little Victor. The ones I remember. There were others, and early others sent to Limbo; they came and went before they could be named. God took them all. He needed them all up there to light the night. He left her plenty, though. The ugly ones, the noisy ones, the ones He didn't want — the ones that would never stay fed.

Poor Mother. She wasn't much more than twenty when she gazed up at little twinkling Henry but she was already old, already decomposing, ruined beyond repair, good for some more babies, then finished.

Poor Mammy. Her own mother was a leathery old witch, but was probably less than forty. She poked me, as if to prove that I was there.

—You're big, she said.

She was accusing me, weighing me, planning to take some of me back. Always wrapped in her black shawl, she always smelt of rotten meat and herrings — it was a sweat on her. Always with a book under the shawl, the complete works of Shakespeare or something by Tolstoy. Nash was her name but I don't know what she called herself before she married her dead husband. She'd no Christian name that I ever heard. Granny Nash was all she ever was. I don't know where she came from; I don't remember an accent. Wrapped in her sweating black shawl, she could have crept out of any century. She might have walked from Roscommon or Clare, pushed on by the stench of the blight, walked across the country till she saw the stone-eating smoke that lay over the piled, sagging fever-nests that made our beautiful city, walked in along the river, deeper and deeper, into the filth and shit, the noise and the money. A young country girl, never kissed, never touched, she was scared, she was thrilled. She turned around and back around and saw the four corners of hell. Her heart cried for Leitrim but her tits sang for Dublin. She got down on her back and yelled at the sailors to form a queue. Frenchmen, Danes, Chinamen, the Yanks. I don't know. A young country girl, a waif, just a child, aching for food. She'd left her family dead in a ditch, their chops green with grass juice, their bellies set to explode in the noonday sun. I don't know any of this. She might have been Dublin-bred. Or she might have been foreign. A workhouse orphan, a nun gone wrong. Transported from Australia, too ugly and bad for Van Diemen's Land. I don't know. She'd become a witch by the time I saw her. Always with her head in a book, looking for spells. She shoved her face forward with ancient certainty, knew every thought behind my eyes. She knew how far evil could drop. She stared at me with her cannibal's eyes and I had to dash down to the privy. Her eyes slammed the door after me.

And what do I know about poor Mother? Precious little. I know that she was Melody Nash. A beautiful name, promising so much. I know that she was born in Dublin and that she lived on Bolton Street. She worked in Mitchell's rosary bead factory on Marlborough Street. They made the beads out of cows' horns. All day, six days a week, sweating, going blind for God and Mitchell. Putting the holes in the beads for Jesus. Hands bleeding, eyes itching. Before she walked into my father.

Melody Nash. I think of the name and I don't see my mother. Melody melody. She skips, she laughs, her black eyes shine happy. Her blue-black hair dances, her feet lick the cobbles. Her teacher is fond of her, she's a fast learner. She's quick at the adding, her letters curl beautifully. She has a great future, she'll marry a big noise. She'll have good meat each day and a house with a jacks. Out of the way, here comes melody Melody, out of the way, here comes melody Melody.

What age was she when she learnt the truth, when she found out that her life would have no music? The name was a lie, a spell the witch put on her. She was twelve when she walked into Mitchell's bead factory and she was sixteen when she walked into my father. Four years in between, squinting, counting, shredding her hands, in a black hole making beads. Melody melody rosary beads. They sang as they worked. Beautiful dreamer, awake unto me. Mitchell wanted them to pray. Starlight and dewdrops are waiting for thee. Was she gorgeous? Did her white teeth gleam as she lifted her head with the other girls? Beautiful dreamer, queen of my song. The woman on the step had no teeth, nothing gleamed. Like me, she was never a child. There were no children in Dublin. Promises weren't kept in the slums. She was never beautiful.

She walked into my father. Melody Nash met Henry Smart. She walked right into him, and he fell. She was half his weight, half his height, six years younger but he fell straight over like a cut tree. Love at first sight? Felled by her beauty? No. He was maggoty drunk and missing his leg. He was holding himself up with a number seven shovel he'd found inside an open door somewhere back the way he'd come when Melody Nash walked into him and dropped him onto Dorset Street. It was a Sunday. She was coming from half-eight mass, he was struggling out of Saturday. Missing a leg and his sense of direction, he hit the street with his forehead and lay still. Melody dropped the beads she'd made herself and stared down at the man. She couldn't see his face; it was kissing the street. She saw a huge back, a back as big as a bed, inside a coat as old and crusted as the cobbles around it. Shovel-sized hands at the end of his outstretched arms, and one leg. Just the one. She actually lifted the coat to check.

—Where's your leg gone, mister? said Melody.

She lifted the coat a bit more.

—Are you dead, mister? she said.
 
I don't know of you'll be able to find them (sadly, they're out of print), but Chuck Rosenthal's Loop Trilogy (Loop's Progress, Experiments with Life and Deaf, and Loop's End) would make a nice addition. Instead of taking the approach of merely reciting or retelling childhood traumas, Rosenthal has his narrator see them through the lens of memory, giving them a sort of magical quality. It is the palliative function of art in full force.
That is to say, the narrator, now in "control" of the events, is able to recast, or re-imagine, a childhood tinged with violence, abuse, poverty, etc. in a light which makes them, not just acceptable, but strangely beautiful.
 
Back
Top