• Welcome to BookAndReader!

    We LOVE books and hope you'll join us in sharing your favorites and experiences along with your love of reading with our community. Registering for our site is free and easy, just CLICK HERE!

    Already a member and forgot your password? Click here.

Help - needs a title/comments

Ell

Well-Known Member
This piece started out as this:

Cold, wet, shivering
What a forlorn bunch we must look.
Like a scene from a clichéd movie.
Huddled under the white canopy
Sagging under the weight of accumulated water
Slowly dripping off the sides
Until a gust of wind sends a huge slosh over the edge.
A collective gasp as everyone jumps
To avoid the inevitable splash onto an already sodden ground.
Quickly we regroup,
Clinging to each other for warmth, support and whatever else our souls need


And became this:

Cold, wet, shivering. What a forlorn bunch; like a scene from a clichéd movie: Wide-angle shot, dark grey mountains in the background, sky slate grey, distant drone of a single-engine plane. Camera slowly zooms in towards a white tent-like structure and small cluster of people gathered on a hillside. The sound of driving, torrential rain increases. Camera finally closes on one face . . .

Huddled under the white canopy sagging from the weight of accumulated water. The water slowly drip, dripping over the sides until a gust of wind sends a huge slosh over the edge. There's a collective gasp as everyone jumps to avoid the inevitable splash onto already sodden ground.
She clutches her husband's arm a little tighter as though it will make her warmer, safer; take away the chill and the growing knot at the pit of her stomach. She can't tell if she's numb from the cold or is beyond feeling.

- The past week had been hectic. Plans, decisions, keeping emotions in check, sometimes getting annoyed but always in control - in control until one innocuous remark about the wording of the obituary sent her running into the bathroom to sob uncontrollably. When she finally came out, her brother was there. "It's okay." "I'm not usually like this." "I know. But it's okay". A big bear hug, a few more tears and she was ready to face everyone again. –

Well, here they are. She looks around to see her sons; somber and so grown-up; the oldest with his girlfriend clinging to him in much the same way she is clinging to her husband. Brother and his wife, the same. The circle of life? Who knows. But there's at least one person with no one to cling to anymore. Shouldn't she be thinking some deep philosophical thoughts, her life flashing before her eyes – no that's when you die yourself, silly. All she feels is a profound emptiness. Maybe the deep thoughts will come later.

A few words are spoken. People file past and sprinkle sand. Finally, she gets up and joins her sisters in placing single roses on the coffin. Others leave now, but she remains with her family to watch the actual interment. The bulldozer and mechanized crane seems out of place, but real gravediggers have given way to modern efficiency. After a few misalignments with the lowering straps, the coffin scrapes and bumps its way down and the first clumps of dirt fall thudding on the coffin lid. It all really comes down to this doesn't it? The end of a life. The finality hits her.

Yet, as she walks back to her car she remembers where she is going: a celebration of life memorial. Yes, memories live on. Remembered kindness and good deeds live on. The legacy of a warm gentle philosophy passed onto sons and daughters live on. Not so final after all. And just like in the movies, it's stopped raining.
 
How about: "Finality--a Celebration..."

Nice piece. I like the prose better than the poetry. Do you plan to go on with it, or is it just a bit of flashfic?
 
Yes, the poetry's pretty lame, but gave me a jumping-off point.

It's something outside my usual comfort zone, hence posting here for feedback. Wondered about the ending. When I started, it was quite dark and bleak, but the narrative kind of took over and ended up somewhere I didn't expect.
 
Cathy C said:
How about: "Finality--a Celebration..."

Do you plan to go on with it, or is it just a bit of flashfic?
Cathy, sorry I didn't answer this earlier. I originally thought of it as a 'one of', but may feel compelled to go on. It's quite personal and I've only just started sharing this aspect of my writing publicly.

Not sure about the "celebration" part of the title. Appreciate the input, though.

ell
 
Beautiful prose

Great development from the original poem. Vivid. Well done. Circle of Life could be a heading or One Rainy Day.
 
Ell said:
This piece started out as this:

Cold, wet, shivering
What a forlorn bunch we must look.
Like a scene from a clichéd movie.
Huddled under the white canopy
Sagging under the weight of accumulated water
Slowly dripping off the sides
Until a gust of wind sends a huge slosh over the edge.
A collective gasp as everyone jumps
To avoid the inevitable splash onto an already sodden ground.
Quickly we regroup,
Clinging to each other for warmth, support and whatever else our souls need


Honestly, this piece is more meaningful as a whole than any particular sentence when I wanted to pick up. I mean, every sentence had certain meaning in itself. but as I wanted to single one out, it seemed to have lost something embedded. For example, I once tried to pick this one: Quickly we regroup,
Clinging to each other for warmth, support and whatever else our souls need
, however, it seemed to be of less significance/meaning. well, no offensive, I mean, it seemed just a bit common, less outstanding. it's lost some of its flavor when stood on its own.


Ell said:
Cold, wet, shivering. What a forlorn bunch; like a scene from a clichéd movie: Wide-angle shot, dark grey mountains in the background, sky slate grey, distant drone of a single-engine plane. Camera slowly zooms in towards a white tent-like structure and small cluster of people gathered on a hillside. The sound of driving, torrential rain increases. Camera finally closes on one face . . .

a cliched movie or a cliched life? I have some similar experiences of that. and I can claim that I have understood what you meant here. (or just my own interpretatioin?)

Ell said:
Huddled under the white canopy sagging from the weight of accumulated water. The water slowly drip, dripping over the sides until a gust of wind sends a huge slosh over the edge. There's a collective gasp as everyone jumps to avoid the inevitable splash onto already sodden ground.
She clutches her husband's arm a little tighter as though it will make her warmer, safer; take away the chill and the growing knot at the pit of her stomach. She can't tell if she's numb from the cold or is beyond feeling.

- The past week had been hectic. Plans, decisions, keeping emotions in check, sometimes getting annoyed but always in control - in control until one innocuous remark about the wording of the obituary sent her running into the bathroom to sob uncontrollably. When she finally came out, her brother was there. "It's okay." "I'm not usually like this." "I know. But it's okay". A big bear hug, a few more tears and she was ready to face everyone again. –

I have now realized that the most bitter, painful and regretful thing in the world was that you had to control yourself when there was so much on your heart or inside you. you never really had a chance to vent out. it was there, accumulating itself. and you lived in a fear of noname. we looked around for support from others when there was some hard time. But the support was only temporary and superfacial. Things ran deep and secretive.

"I'm not usually like this."--------*lots of mixed feelings*


Ell said:
Well, here they are. She looks around to see her sons; somber and so grown-up; the oldest with his girlfriend clinging to him in much the same way she is clinging to her husband. Brother and his wife, the same. The circle of life? Who knows. But there's at least one person with no one to cling to anymore. Shouldn't she be thinking some deep philosophical thoughts, her life flashing before her eyes – no that's when you die yourself, silly. All she feels is a profound emptiness. Maybe the deep thoughts will come later.

A few words are spoken. People file past and sprinkle sand. Finally, she gets up and joins her sisters in placing single roses on the coffin. Others leave now, but she remains with her family to watch the actual interment. The bulldozer and mechanized crane seems out of place, but real gravediggers have given way to modern efficiency. After a few misalignments with the lowering straps, the coffin scrapes and bumps its way down and the first clumps of dirt fall thudding on the coffin lid. It all really comes down to this doesn't it? The end of a life. The finality hits her.

Yet, as she walks back to her car she remembers where she is going: a celebration of life memorial. Yes, memories live on. Remembered kindness and good deeds live on. The legacy of a warm gentle philosophy passed onto sons and daughters live on. Not so final after all. And just like in the movies, it's stopped raining.


we only exist in memories. life leaves its mark in lives of others, but we would never know or see. Because the mark doesn't belong to us.

As for the title, how about "No Subject I"?

Don't think the feedback would help. anyway. I might edit it again. :eek:


Wish you the same, a happy and healthy 2005! My bests, :)

watercrystal
 
Eugen, I like "Circle of Life".

watercrystal, I agree with you about the last lines of the poem. Rather ordinary. Probably why I ended up writing the prose instead. Methinks poetry is not my thing!
 
Ell, I loved it that you let us in on the beginning, that is your initial impulse to record the experience in the form of poetry first. I liked reading the two versions together like that. You made us struggle for an understanding of what is happening to the narrator -- in effect letting us see inside to her own struggle to comprend the meaning of this loss.

Well, here they are. She looks around to see her sons; somber and so grown-up; the oldest with his girlfriend clinging to him in much the same way she is clinging to her husband. Brother and his wife, the same. The circle of life? Who knows. But there's at least one person with no one to cling to anymore. Shouldn't she be thinking some deep philosophical thoughts, her life flashing before her eyes – no that's when you die yourself, silly. All she feels is a profound emptiness. Maybe the deep thoughts will come later.

What I am imagining is that the narrator's father has died, but that he was not married to her own mother...

Let me know if I'm on the right track?

Now I'm on to your next piece.
 
I think that you've really done an excellent job here. You've done well in capturing the feelings of many people when they lose loved ones. If I were to suggest a title for this I would probably suggest, "The Illusion of a Hope".
 
Back
Top