• Welcome to BookAndReader!

    We LOVE books and hope you'll join us in sharing your favorites and experiences along with your love of reading with our community. Registering for our site is free and easy, just CLICK HERE!

    Already a member and forgot your password? Click here.

Susan Kay: Phantom

ValkyrieRaven88

New Member
Has anyone else read this? It was self-published, so it's not as well-known as it probably should be. But it is a really good book. I love The Phantom of the Opera, but this book was even better.
The story opens with Erik (the Phantom's) birth. He was born with the face of a corpse, instantly ruining the life of his beautiful and popular mother. Madeleine is trapped in her house with the monster-child whose talent and genius frighten her more than his face.
It goes through Erik's time with the gypsies as "The Living Corpse" (a reference to the musical where he was "The Devil's Child"), his studies of architecture, his travels in Persia as a magician, the building of the Paris opera house, and his tragic romance with Christine Daae. There is a slight surprise at the end, told in Raoul's point of view.
The way Susan Kay added flesh to Erik's character amazed me. Erik could easily have become what some of us call a Mary Sue--a character who is too perfect to be real and utterly unbelievable--but his black moods, temper, and inability to distinguish between right and wrong take quite a different angle.
I would reccomend this to fans of the musical and/or book The Phantom of the Opera, but you don't need to be familiar with either to enjoy it. This was one of the best books I ever read, and that's a hard title to get out of me. Erik always surprised and impressed me, and the segments of Erik's strange life were placed together well.
 
I started reading Phantom last night. I've had a few people recommend it to me and it took me awhile to track down a copy.
 
I finished today and it was a wonderful book. I think she did an excellant job of telling Erik's story and I really loved it. The balance of emotions was just right, you felt bad for Erik but not too bad, he often did things to ensure that you didn't pity him completely but you understood how he came about doing them. The other people that came into the story were well balanced too, I liked the way each had their own section to tell. All in all very worth the effort to track down and the extra dollars I had to spend.
 
Yes, I liked that very much. Kay is a gifted author and the story was wonderful. I'm glad you had the chance to enjoy it! ^_^
 
Back
Top