Inderjit S
New Member
SillyWabbit-I understand what you mean now-you think Tolkien is a pedant, and I agree with you, but which author isn't? Well, I enjoy Tolkien's pedantry as I like to know every detail of Tolkien's world. But never mind, each to his own is what I say.
But there is one more gripe-how can all of Tolkien's characters be 'dull'? Can you really homogenize a whole bunch of different characters as being boring and dull? Though, I must admit, I am being a tad hypocritical, since I find all of Jane Austen's characters, with the possible exception of Mr. Knightley to be amazingly dull, though Tolkien has a lot more character variation then Jane Austen.
But there is one more gripe-how can all of Tolkien's characters be 'dull'? Can you really homogenize a whole bunch of different characters as being boring and dull? Though, I must admit, I am being a tad hypocritical, since I find all of Jane Austen's characters, with the possible exception of Mr. Knightley to be amazingly dull, though Tolkien has a lot more character variation then Jane Austen.